Bethpage, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Bethpage, NY

Is Bethpage, NY safe?

Bethpage ranks as one of the safest communities in Nassau County, earning an overall crime grade of A- on our 2026 crime map. Every neighborhood analyzed — Bethpage and Plainedge — received an A-range grade, meaning 100% of Bethpage neighborhoods fall into the "safe" tier (grades A or B). With a poverty rate of just 3.3% and a median household income of $115,413, the socioeconomic conditions that typically correlate with lower crime are firmly in place here. Residents consistently report a strong sense of community safety, and the data backs that up.

What is the crime rate in Bethpage compared to other areas?

Bethpage's crime profile is exceptionally favorable. The city-wide safety rating is classified as Very Safe (A), and across both analyzed neighborhoods, 100% earned an A-range grade — none received a B, C, D, or F. For context, many suburban communities see 20–40% of their neighborhoods fall into lower safety tiers; Bethpage has zero. Property crimes such as occasional vehicle theft and larceny represent the most common incident types, while violent crime remains extremely rare. The combination of low unemployment (4.7%) and a very low poverty rate (3.3%) helps keep overall crime figures well below national and regional benchmarks.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Bethpage?

Both analyzed neighborhoods in Bethpage score at the top of the safety scale:

• Plainedge — Grade: A+: The highest-rated area in Bethpage, Plainedge is home to approximately 9,095 residents and has a median household income of $133,563. It represents the gold standard for safety in this community, with incident rates among the lowest recorded in the region.
• Bethpage — Grade: A: The core Bethpage neighborhood, with roughly 16,853 residents and a median household income of $119,633, also earns a top-tier safety grade. While it ranks just below Plainedge, an A grade still places it in the top safety category by any measure.

Both neighborhoods benefit from strong homeownership rates, high median incomes, and active community engagement — all factors that research consistently links to lower crime.

Is Bethpage a good place to live in 2026?

By nearly every measurable indicator, yes. Here is a quick snapshot of why Bethpage stands out:

• Safety: Overall crime grade of A-, with 100% of neighborhoods rated A or above.
• Income: Median household income of $115,413 — well above the national median.
• Home values: Median home value of $504,294, reflecting strong real estate demand and neighborhood stability.
• Affordability context: Median rent of $2,509 is consistent with the broader Nassau County market for a community of this caliber.
• Economic health: Unemployment sits at 4.7% and the poverty rate is only 3.3%, both indicators of a resilient local economy.
• Density: At 1,944 residents per square mile, Bethpage offers a suburban feel with enough density to support local amenities without the congestion of urban areas.

For families, professionals, and retirees alike, Bethpage's combination of top safety grades, strong incomes, and stable housing market makes it one of Long Island's most desirable places to call home in 2026.

Which part of Bethpage has the most crime?

Even the "highest crime" area in Bethpage is objectively very safe. The Bethpage neighborhood itself carries a Grade A — the second-highest possible rating — while Plainedge earns an A+. Neither area shows concentrations of violent crime. The most frequently reported incident types across the community are minor property-related offenses such as vehicle larceny and occasional vandalism, which are common in virtually all suburban communities of similar density. No neighborhood in Bethpage falls below an A grade, making meaningful crime-hotspot distinctions within the hamlet largely academic.

How does Bethpage's safety compare to the rest of Nassau County?

Bethpage performs exceptionally well within Nassau County's safety landscape. With 100% of its neighborhoods graded A or A+, Bethpage outperforms many neighboring communities where mixed B and C grades are common. The hamlet's low poverty rate (3.3%), high median income ($115,413), and low unemployment (4.7%) create a socioeconomic environment that is strongly associated with sustained low crime over time. Residents of both Plainedge and the Bethpage core neighborhood benefit from this stability, and the 2026 crime map data confirms that the area's strong safety reputation is well-earned.