Central Islip, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Central Islip, NY

Is Central Islip, NY safe to live in?

Yes, Central Islip earns a city-wide safety rating of B (Safe) based on neighborhood-level crime analysis. When broken down by area, 100% of the neighborhoods analyzed — including the Central Islip neighborhood itself — received a grade of B+ or higher, placing them firmly in the top safety tier. For context, the community has a population of approximately 33,591 residents spread across a density of 1,812 people per square mile, and the data shows no neighborhoods falling into the C, D, or F grade ranges. That means every assessed area qualifies as safe by our grading standards.

What is the overall crime grade for Central Islip?

Central Islip carries an overall crime grade of D+ at the city level — a metric that factors in broader regional comparisons. However, at the neighborhood level, the picture is notably better: the Central Islip neighborhood specifically scores a B+, and 100% of analyzed neighborhoods fall into the A–B (safe) category. This contrast highlights that while the city-level grade reflects some regional crime pressure, the residential neighborhoods themselves perform well above average. Residents with a median household income of $79,645 and a median home value of $297,965 are living in areas that score in the top safety band.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Central Islip?

Based on our crime map data, the Central Islip neighborhood is the top-rated area, earning a grade of B+. It is home to roughly 34,075 residents and has a median household income of approximately $86,020 — notably higher than the city-wide median of $79,645. This income differential often correlates with lower property crime exposure, and the B+ grade confirms that pattern here. With 100% of analyzed neighborhoods landing in the safe (B or above) category, Central Islip stands out as a consistently reliable community from a safety standpoint.

How does Central Islip's crime compare to other New York communities?

At the neighborhood level, Central Islip performs well: 100% of its neighborhoods are graded B or higher, with zero neighborhoods receiving a C, D, or F. The city-level grade of D+ reflects comparisons against a broader statewide or national baseline, which can be influenced by regional crime patterns beyond individual neighborhood conditions. The unemployment rate of 3.8% and poverty rate of 9.4% are both relatively modest figures, which typically support lower crime environments. For a Long Island community of 33,591 people, a neighborhood-level B+ rating is a meaningful indicator of day-to-day safety.

Is Central Islip a good place to buy a home or raise a family?

The data points to several encouraging indicators. The median home value is $297,965 and the median household income is $79,645, suggesting a stable housing market relative to income. The unemployment rate sits at 3.8% and the poverty rate at 9.4% — both figures that indicate a reasonably healthy local economy. On the safety front, the Central Islip neighborhood holds a B+ crime grade, and the city-wide neighborhood analysis shows 100% of areas rated safe (B or above). Median rent of $1,803 reflects a competitive but accessible rental market. Taken together, these figures make Central Islip a reasonable choice for families and professionals weighing safety, affordability, and community stability on Long Island.