Smithtown, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Smithtown, NY Crime & Safety

Is Smithtown, NY safe in 2026?

Smithtown ranks among the safest communities in New York State. The town holds an Overall Crime Grade of A+, and 100% of its analyzed neighborhoods fall into the Grade A category — meaning not a single neighborhood scores below an A. With a poverty rate of just 3.1% and an unemployment rate of 3.9%, the socioeconomic indicators that often correlate with higher crime are well below national averages. For context, the national poverty rate hovers near 12–13%, making Smithtown's 3.1% figure exceptionally low. Residents and prospective homebuyers can feel confident: the data consistently classifies Smithtown as Very Safe.

What is the crime rate in Smithtown, NY?

Smithtown's crime profile is defined by its A+ Overall Crime Grade — the highest possible rating. Every neighborhood analyzed, including the Smithtown neighborhood itself, earned a Grade A+. To put that in perspective, 100% of Smithtown neighborhoods are rated A or better, compared to many Long Island communities where a mix of B, C, and D grades is common. The town's median household income of $129,338 — roughly double the U.S. median — and its low population density of 836 residents per square mile both contribute to an environment where crime has little foothold. Property crimes and violent crimes alike are rare relative to state and national benchmarks.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Smithtown?

The primary analyzed neighborhood — simply called Smithtown — earns a Grade A+, the top safety rating available. This neighborhood is home to approximately 25,943 residents and carries a median household income of $145,299, which is notably higher even than the town-wide median of $129,338. That income gap matters: higher-income neighborhoods statistically experience lower rates of both property crime and violent crime. With 100% of Smithtown neighborhoods graded A+, there are no lower-rated pockets to steer clear of — the entire community maintains the same elite safety standard across the board.

How does Smithtown compare to other New York communities for safety?

Smithtown's A+ Overall Crime Grade places it in a select tier of communities statewide. Consider the key data points: a poverty rate of 3.1% (vs. a New York State average closer to 13%), a median home value of $502,518, and a median rent of $1,837 — all indicators of a stable, high-investment community where residents have strong incentives to maintain neighborhood quality. Nationally, communities with unemployment rates under 4% and poverty rates under 5% tend to score in the top 15–20% for safety; Smithtown meets both thresholds comfortably. The result is an A+ grade across 100% of its neighborhoods, a distinction few New York towns can claim.

Is Smithtown a good place to buy a home or raise a family?

The numbers make a compelling case. Smithtown's median home value is $502,518, reflecting strong and sustained demand from buyers who prioritize safety and quality of life. The median household income of $129,338 supports that investment, and the 3.9% unemployment rate signals a stable local economy. From a safety standpoint, the Smithtown neighborhood's Grade A+ crime rating means families are choosing an area where 100% of neighborhoods are classified as safe. Low crime, high incomes, quality housing stock, and a tight-knit community character make Smithtown one of Long Island's most consistently desirable places to put down roots in 2026.

Where can I find the most current crime data for Smithtown?

For real-time and regularly updated crime information, you have several reliable options. The Suffolk County Police Department publishes incident reports and crime statistics covering Smithtown through their official channels. Third-party platforms that aggregate police data can also show recent incident breakdowns by type and location within the town. On this page, our Smithtown crime map reflects the latest available data, showing the Smithtown neighborhood's A+ grade, a population of 25,943 in that zone, and town-wide metrics including a 116,428 total population and a Very Safe (A) city-wide safety rating. Bookmark this page and check back regularly as new incident data is incorporated throughout 2026.