New Milford, NJ Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in New Milford, NJ

Is New Milford, NJ safe?

New Milford earns an overall crime grade of B, which places it among the safer communities in Bergen County. Looking at the most recent 90 days of incident data (145 total reported events), the vast majority — 70% — were arrests rather than new victimization events, meaning law enforcement is actively responding to and resolving incidents. Theft accounted for 16% of reports (23 incidents), assaults made up 8% (11 incidents), and more serious crimes like burglary (5%, 7 incidents), robbery (1%), and shooting (1%) were comparatively rare. That profile is consistent with a low-crime suburban borough. Neighborhoods near the Hackensack River corridor and the North End consistently show fewer reported incidents on the crime map.

What is the crime rate in New Milford?

New Milford's overall crime performance earns a letter grade of B — above average for a U.S. municipality of its size. Over the last 90 days, the borough logged 145 total incidents. Breaking that down: property-related offenses (theft, burglary combined) accounted for roughly 21% of all incidents — 23 thefts and 7 burglaries. Violent incidents were a small fraction: 11 assaults (8%), 1 robbery (1%), and 1 shooting (1%). With a population of approximately 16,477 and a poverty rate of just 4.9%, New Milford's socioeconomic profile supports its relatively favorable crime standing. The median household income of $94,821 also correlates with the community's capacity to invest in safety infrastructure and neighborhood watch programs.

What types of crime are most common in New Milford?

Based on the last 90 days of data, theft is the most prevalent crime category, representing 16% of all 145 incidents (23 events), with the most recent theft recorded as recently as March 3, 2026. Assaults were the second most common offense type at 8% (11 incidents, latest March 1, 2026). Burglary accounted for 5% (7 incidents, latest February 28, 2026). Robbery and shooting each represented just 1% of total incidents — a combined 2 events over the entire 90-day window. This distribution suggests that property crime — particularly opportunistic theft — is the primary concern for New Milford residents, while violent crime remains relatively uncommon. Areas near commercial corridors tend to see a higher share of theft incidents, while residential zones like the North End report fewer property offenses overall.

What are the safest neighborhoods in New Milford?

While New Milford is a compact borough spanning roughly 2,786 residents per square mile, crime is not evenly distributed. The North End and areas adjacent to Pascack Brook tend to appear less frequently on the crime map. Given that theft (16% of incidents) is the dominant offense type, quieter residential pockets away from main commercial routes generally see fewer reports. The borough's B-grade overall safety rating reflects that the majority of its neighborhoods are low-risk for serious violent crime — with shooting and robbery together comprising only 2 incidents in the past 90 days across the entire town.

Is New Milford a good place to live in 2026?

By the numbers, New Milford presents a compelling case. The borough holds an overall crime grade of B, a median household income of $94,821, a median home value of $431,657, and a poverty rate of just 4.9% — all indicators of a stable, relatively prosperous community. The recent 90-day crime snapshot reinforces that picture: 70% of the 145 logged incidents were arrests, meaning police are actively clearing cases rather than leaving crimes unresolved. Serious violent events (robbery and shooting) accounted for only 2 out of 145 incidents. The unemployment rate of 6.4% is the one metric worth watching, as elevated unemployment can correlate with property crime over time. Overall, though, New Milford's data profile makes it a strong choice for families, commuters, and retirees seeking suburban safety in Bergen County.

How can I track crime in New Milford in real time?

The interactive crime map on this page is updated regularly and lets you filter by incident type — theft, assault, burglary, and more — so you can focus on the categories most relevant to your neighborhood. For official reports, the New Milford Police Department publishes incident logs and community alerts. Third-party platforms like CrimeMapping.com can supplement that data with a visual heat-map layer. Given that theft (16%) and burglary (5%) are the leading property crime categories in recent data, setting up alerts for those incident types is a practical first step for residents who want to stay ahead of local trends.