Old City Neighborhood, Saint Augustine

Crime Rate & Statistics

A

Very safe neighborhood — well below-average crime rates

Safer than 35% of neighborhoods in Saint Augustine

Safety at a Glance

Overall Crime Moderate
Low 148 / 300 High
Violent Crime 150
50% above national avg
Property Crime 166
66% above national avg
City Ranking
35%
safer than other
Saint Augustine neighborhoods

Check a specific address

in Saint Augustine

Is Old City Safe?

Yes — this neighborhood is very safe. Old City in Saint Augustine, FL has a safety grade of A. The overall crime index is 148, which is 48% above the national average of 100. Old City is safer than 35% of neighborhoods in Saint Augustine.

Compared to the Saint Augustine average (crime index 108), Old City is 40% higher in overall crime. Residents and visitors should exercise extra caution in this area, particularly after dark.

Looking at specific crime types, assault is the most elevated concern (index: 194, 94% above average), while rape is the lowest risk (index: 84).

Highest Risk
Assault · Index 194 (94% above avg)
Lowest Risk
Rape · Index 84 (16% below avg)

Old City Crime Breakdown

Crime indices compared to national average (100) and Saint Augustine city average. Higher values mean more crime.

Crime Type Index vs National Risk Level
Violent Crime
Murder
144 +44% Moderate
Assault
194 +94% High
Robbery
176 +76% High
Rape
84 -16% Average
Property Crime
Burglary
153 +53% High
Larceny / Theft
186 +86% High
Vehicle Theft
158 +58% High

How Old City Compares

Crime index by category: Old City vs Saint Augustine average vs national average.

Crime by Category

Overall Crime Comparison

Old City Crime Map

Crime heatmap based on block-group level data. Red areas indicate higher crime density.

Full Screen Map
Crime Level: Low Below Avg Average Above Avg High

See the crime score for a specific address

Old City Demographics & Context

Population
311
Median Income
$79,849
Home Value
$672,639
Median Age
67
Pop. Density
2,416/mi²

Education

Bachelor's Degree 26.9%
Graduate Degree 35.1%

Housing

56%
44%
Owner-occupied Renter-occupied

Racial Demographics

White 94.9%
Black 2.9%
Hispanic 3.5%
Asian 1%

Nearby Neighborhoods

Lincolnville Index: 198
B-
Spanish Quarter Index: 119
A+
Flagler's Model Land Index: 103
A
North Davis Shores Index: 118
A+
South Davis Shores Index: 111
A+
Uptown Index: 178
A
Lighthouse Park Index: 118
A+
Royal St. Augustine Index: 156
A-
Old City Crime Map
Interactive crime heatmap for this neighborhood
Saint Augustine Crime Statistics
View all Saint Augustine neighborhoods & city-wide data

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the crime rate in Old City, Saint Augustine?

Old City in Saint Augustine, FL has a crime safety grade of A as of 2026. The overall crime index is 148, which is 48% above the national average. Compared to the Saint Augustine average, crime in Old City is 40% higher. Old City is safer than 35% of neighborhoods in Saint Augustine.

Is Old City a safe neighborhood in Saint Augustine?

Old City is generally considered a safe neighborhood in Saint Augustine, earning a crime grade of A. The highest concern is Assault (index: 194), while Rape is the lowest risk (index: 84).

How does Old City compare to the rest of Saint Augustine?

Old City's overall crime index is 148, compared to the Saint Augustine average of 108. This means crime in Old City is 40% higher than the city average. For violent crime, the index is 150, and for property crime it is 166. However, crime can vary block by block, so checking the crime map for specific streets is recommended.

What type of crime is most common in Old City?

The most prevalent crime type in Old City is Assault, with a crime index of 194 (94% above the national average). Overall, property crime is more prevalent than violent crime in this neighborhood, which is consistent with national trends.

What are safer neighborhoods near Old City?

Nearby neighborhoods with good safety ratings include Lincolnville, Spanish Quarter, Flagler's Model Land and North Davis Shores. These areas are close to Old City and offer lower crime rates, making them worth considering for residents who prioritize safety.

What are the demographics of Old City?

Old City has a population of approximately 311. The median household income is $79,849. The median home value is $672,639. Research shows that economic factors can correlate with crime rates, though many other variables play a role in neighborhood safety.

How does Old City crime compare to the national average?

Old City's overall crime rate is 48% above the national average (index 148 vs 100). Within Saint Augustine, it is safer than 35% of neighborhoods. For the most accurate picture, review the per-crime-type breakdown above, as some categories may differ significantly from the overall trend.

Crime data sourced from FBI UCR reports and local law enforcement agencies. Crime indices use 100 as the national average. Updated April 2026.