Montauk, NY Crime Rate & Safety
Lower crime than 89% of major U.S. cities
Based on FBI UCR & local law enforcement data · Updated April 2026
Is Montauk Safe?
Yes — Montauk is safe overall
A safe city with below-average crime, though safety varies by neighborhood.
Montauk has a crime rate that is 47% below the national average. Your chance of becoming a victim of violent crime is 1 in 664.
However, safety varies dramatically by neighborhood. Areas like Montauk earn an A safety grade, while Montauk rates A. Understanding which neighborhoods are safe is critical for anyone living in, moving to, or visiting Montauk.
Crime Index Comparison
100 = national average. Calibrated to reflect actual crime severity.
Your Chance of Being a Victim
Violent Crime
1 in 664
chance per year
National average: 1 in 263
60% lower than national average
Property Crime
1 in 236
chance per year
National average: 1 in 55
77% lower than national average
Want to know the crime risk at your exact address?
Montauk Crime Breakdown
Estimated crime rates based on FBI UCR data, calibrated to city-level crime score.
| Crime Type | Index | vs National | Risk Level | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Violent Crime | ||||
|
Murder
|
27 | -73% | Low | |
|
Assault
|
52 | -48% | Low | |
|
Robbery
|
10 | -90% | Low | |
|
Rape
|
4 | -96% | Low | |
| Property Crime | ||||
|
Burglary
|
51 | -49% | Low | |
|
Larceny / Theft
|
20 | -80% | Low | |
|
Vehicle Theft
|
0 | -100% | Low | |
Violent vs Property Crime
Crime Index by Category
Montauk Crime Map
Neighborhood-level crime heatmap. Click any area for details.
See the crime score for a specific address
Where Is It Safe in Montauk?
Safety varies dramatically across Montauk's 1+ neighborhoods.
Safest Neighborhoods
Top 1Areas with Higher Crime
Bottom 1Neighborhood Safety Distribution
Out of 1 neighborhoods in Montauk
All Montauk Neighborhoods
| # | Neighborhood | Grade | Crime Index |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Montauk | A | 196 |
Montauk Crime by Zip Code
Explore crime data for specific Montauk zip codes.
Montauk Demographics & Context
Racial Demographics
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the crime rate in Montauk, NY?
Montauk, NY has a crime safety grade of A- as of 2026. The overall crime rate is estimated to be 47% below the national average. Residents face approximately a 1 in 664 chance of being a victim of violent crime per year and a 1 in 236 chance for property crime. Montauk has lower crime than 89% of major U.S. cities (population 50,000+).
Is Montauk, NY safe to live in?
Montauk is generally considered a safe place to live, earning a crime grade of A-. Approximately 100% of the city's 1 neighborhoods are rated A or B for safety. However, safety varies significantly by neighborhood. For example, Montauk is one of the safest areas, while Montauk has higher crime rates. Researching specific neighborhoods before moving to or visiting Montauk is strongly recommended.
What are the safest neighborhoods in Montauk?
Based on 2026 crime data, the safest neighborhoods in Montauk are Montauk. These areas have significantly lower crime rates than the city average and are popular choices for families, professionals, and anyone prioritizing safety.
What are the most dangerous areas in Montauk?
The neighborhoods with the highest crime rates in Montauk include Montauk. These areas experience significantly more crime than the city average. Visitors and prospective residents should exercise extra caution in these neighborhoods, particularly at night.
What is the violent crime rate in Montauk?
The estimated violent crime rate in Montauk is 150.5 per 100,000 residents, which is 60% lower than the national average. This means residents have roughly a 1 in 664 chance of becoming a violent crime victim each year. Key violent crime rates include: murder at 1.4 per 100K (73% below average); aggravated assault at 140.5 per 100K (48% below average); robbery at 7.3 per 100K (90% below average).
What is the property crime rate in Montauk?
The estimated property crime rate in Montauk is 423.8 per 100,000 residents, which is 77% lower than the national average. Residents have roughly a 1 in 236 chance of being a property crime victim per year. Key property crime rates include: burglary at 137.7 per 100K (49% below average); larceny/theft at 286.1 per 100K (80% below average); vehicle theft at 0.0 per 100K (100% below average).
How does Montauk crime compare to the national average?
Montauk's overall crime rate is 47% below the national average as of 2026. The biggest concern is assault (48% below average), while vehicle theft is 100% below average. Compared to other major U.S. cities, Montauk has lower crime than 89% of them.
Is Montauk safe to visit?
Montauk is generally safe for visitors and tourists. Property crime (theft, vehicle break-ins) is 77% below average, which is typically the main concern for tourists. Avoid leaving valuables in vehicles, stay aware of your surroundings in unfamiliar areas, and stick to well-traveled neighborhoods. Popular, safer areas for visitors include Montauk.
How does Montauk crime compare to the rest of New York?
New York as a whole has crime that is 1% above the national average. Montauk's crime rate is 47% below the national average, making it safer the typical New York city.
What type of crime is most common in Montauk?
Larceny/theft is the most common crime in Montauk, with an estimated rate of 286.1 incidents per 100,000 residents. This is 80% below the national average for this crime type. Overall, property crime (424 per 100K) is more prevalent than violent crime (151 per 100K) in Montauk, which is consistent with national trends.