Farmingville, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Farmingville, NY Crime & Safety

Is Farmingville, NY safe?

Farmingville earns an overall crime grade of A-, placing it firmly in the "Very Safe" category. In fact, 100% of the analyzed neighborhoods within Farmingville carry a Grade A rating — meaning not a single area falls into the B, C, D, or F tiers. With a population of 16,705 and a poverty rate of just 2.2%, the socioeconomic conditions here strongly support low crime levels. By comparison, most U.S. suburban communities of similar size see a meaningful share of neighborhoods rated B or below; Farmingville is a clear outlier in the best possible way.

What is the crime rate in Farmingville, NY?

Rather than relying on raw numeric scores, our analysis grades Farmingville's crime environment on a letter-grade scale. The community receives an A- overall, with its primary residential area — Farmingville itself — rated A+. That A+ designation reflects the lowest measurable tier of criminal activity on our scale. Contributing factors include a median household income of $113,646 (well above national medians), an unemployment rate of 4.9%, and a poverty rate of only 2.2% — all indicators strongly correlated with reduced crime. The combined share of neighborhoods rated A or B (our "Safe" benchmark) stands at 100%, with Grade A neighborhoods accounting for the full 100% of that figure.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Farmingville?

Farmingville's neighborhood-level data shows a remarkably uniform safety picture. The primary neighborhood — Farmingville — holds a Grade A+ rating, the highest designation on our scale. This neighborhood is home to roughly 15,194 residents and carries a median household income of $122,309, which is notably higher than the hamlet-wide median of $113,646. The Grade A+ rating means residents here experience the lowest observable levels of both property and violent crime. Because 100% of analyzed neighborhoods fall into the Grade A tier, there are no meaningful crime hotspots to flag within Farmingville's boundaries.

How does Farmingville compare to other New York communities?

Farmingville's safety profile is strong even within the context of Suffolk County's generally suburban character. With 100% of neighborhoods graded A and zero neighborhoods rated B, C, D, or F, Farmingville outperforms many comparably sized Long Island hamlets. A median home value of $367,388 and median rent of $2,068 reflect the premium residents pay for this level of safety and community stability. Population density sits at a moderate 1,540 people per square mile — dense enough to support an active community but not so dense as to generate the anonymity often associated with elevated urban crime rates.

Is Farmingville a good place to live in 2026?

The data points toward a strong yes. Farmingville combines an A- overall crime grade with a median household income of $113,646, a poverty rate of 2.2%, and an unemployment rate of 4.9% — a combination that signals both economic health and community stability. The Farmingville neighborhood's A+ safety rating means families, professionals, and retirees can expect a low-crime environment backed by measurable data. With median home values at $367,388 and 100% of local neighborhoods graded A for safety, Farmingville represents one of the more compelling suburban options on Long Island for those prioritizing security alongside quality of life.

What types of crime should residents be aware of in Farmingville?

Even in a community rated A+ for safety, awareness matters. In suburban hamlets with Farmingville's profile — moderate density, high income, low poverty — the most commonly reported incidents tend to be opportunistic property crimes such as vehicle break-ins and minor theft rather than violent offenses. Farmingville's 2.2% poverty rate and strong median income of $113,646 are associated with very low rates of violent crime. Residents are encouraged to use the Suffolk County Police Department's official resources alongside our crime map to stay current on any localized incident patterns, and to report suspicious activity promptly to help maintain the hamlet's A+ standing.