Brentwood, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Brentwood, NY

Is Brentwood, NY safe to live in?

Yes, Brentwood ranks as a Safe (B) community overall, and the primary residential neighborhood — simply called Brentwood — earns an A- safety grade. That puts it among the top tier of Long Island suburbs analyzed on our crime map. With 100% of analyzed neighborhoods graded A or B, no part of Brentwood falls into the concerning C, D, or F categories that appear in many comparable Suffolk County communities. For context, the town's poverty rate sits at 9.3% and the unemployment rate is 4.8% — both relatively contained figures that correlate with the area's stable crime profile.

What is the crime rate in Brentwood, NY?

Brentwood's crime picture is best understood through its grade distribution rather than raw numbers. The main Brentwood neighborhood, home to roughly 58,646 residents, holds an A- grade — meaning it outperforms the majority of neighborhoods nationally on both violent and property crime metrics. At the city-wide level, Brentwood carries an overall crime grade of C-, which reflects broader regional comparisons across all U.S. cities; however, when you zoom into the neighborhood level, the data tells a more reassuring story: 100% of analyzed neighborhoods score in the A-range, with zero neighborhoods graded C, D, or F.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Brentwood, NY?

The top-rated neighborhood in Brentwood is Brentwood itself, graded A-, with a median household income of $82,073 and a population of approximately 58,646. Since it is the primary neighborhood analyzed, it represents the community's dominant safety profile. Residents in this area benefit from a relatively dense suburban setting — 2,212 people per square mile — which often supports natural surveillance and community cohesion, both factors associated with lower crime environments. No neighborhoods in Brentwood were flagged as higher-risk areas in the current dataset.

How does Brentwood's safety compare to other New York suburbs?

Brentwood's A- neighborhood grade positions it favorably against many Long Island and broader New York suburban communities. While the city-wide grade of C- reflects how Brentwood compares across a national baseline that includes large metro areas, the neighborhood-level data shows that 100% of Brentwood's analyzed neighborhoods fall into the safe A-B range — a distinction that many similarly sized communities cannot claim. With a median home value of $332,031 and a median household income of $89,872, Brentwood also demonstrates the economic stability that typically correlates with sustained community safety.

Is Brentwood, NY a good place to raise a family?

The data supports Brentwood as a solid choice for families. Key indicators include: a median household income of $89,872, a median home value of $332,031, and a median rent of $1,407 — offering a range of housing options. The unemployment rate of 4.8% and poverty rate of 9.3% are within manageable ranges for a community of its size (62,743 residents). Most importantly, the Brentwood neighborhood earns an A- safety grade, and the city-wide analysis shows zero neighborhoods graded D or F. Families prioritizing safety alongside affordability relative to the broader New York metro area will find Brentwood's profile encouraging.

What types of crime should residents be most aware of in Brentwood?

While Brentwood's neighborhood-level grades are strong — with the main Brentwood area holding an A- rating — the city's overall C- crime grade signals that property crimes and quality-of-life incidents do occur at a rate worth monitoring. In communities with Brentwood's density (2,212 residents per square mile) and income profile, the most common concerns typically involve property-related incidents such as vehicle break-ins and opportunistic theft. Residents are encouraged to use the interactive crime map on this page to track incident patterns by type and time period, and to report suspicious activity to the Suffolk County Police Department.