Bay Island Neighborhood, Sarasota
Crime Rate & Statistics
One of the safest neighborhoods — significantly below-average crime
Safety at a Glance
Check a specific address
in Sarasota
Is Bay Island Safe?
Yes — this neighborhood is extremely safe. Bay Island in Sarasota, FL has a safety grade of A+. The overall crime index is 85, which is 15% below the national average of 100.
Compared to the Sarasota average (crime index 110), Bay Island is 25% lower in overall crime.
Looking at specific crime types, larceny / theft is the most elevated concern (index: 92, 8% below average), while robbery is the lowest risk (index: 25).
Bay Island Crime Breakdown
Crime indices compared to national average (100) and Sarasota city average. Higher values mean more crime.
| Crime Type | Index | vs National | Risk Level | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Violent Crime | ||||
|
Murder
|
52 | -48% | Low | |
|
Assault
|
91 | -9% | Average | |
|
Robbery
|
25 | -75% | Low | |
|
Rape
|
29 | -71% | Low | |
| Property Crime | ||||
|
Burglary
|
62 | -38% | Low | |
|
Larceny / Theft
|
92 | -8% | Average | |
|
Vehicle Theft
|
41 | -59% | Low | |
How Bay Island Compares
Crime index by category: Bay Island vs Sarasota average vs national average.
Crime by Category
Overall Crime Comparison
Bay Island Crime Map
Crime heatmap based on block-group level data. Red areas indicate higher crime density.
See the crime score for a specific address
Bay Island Demographics & Context
Education
Housing
Racial Demographics
Nearby Neighborhoods
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the crime rate in Bay Island, Sarasota?
Bay Island in Sarasota, FL has a crime safety grade of A+ as of 2026. The overall crime index is 85, which is 15% below the national average. Compared to the Sarasota average, crime in Bay Island is 25% lower.
Is Bay Island a safe neighborhood in Sarasota?
Bay Island is generally considered a safe neighborhood in Sarasota, earning a crime grade of A+. The highest concern is Larceny / Theft (index: 92), while Robbery is the lowest risk (index: 25).
How does Bay Island compare to the rest of Sarasota?
Bay Island's overall crime index is 85, compared to the Sarasota average of 110. This means crime in Bay Island is 25% lower than the city average. For violent crime, the index is 49, and for property crime it is 65. However, crime can vary block by block, so checking the crime map for specific streets is recommended.
What type of crime is most common in Bay Island?
The most prevalent crime type in Bay Island is Larceny / Theft, with a crime index of 92 (8% below the national average). Overall, property crime is more prevalent than violent crime in this neighborhood, which is consistent with national trends.
What are safer neighborhoods near Bay Island?
Nearby neighborhoods with good safety ratings include Lido Key, Bird Key, The Landings and John Ringling. These areas are close to Bay Island and offer lower crime rates, making them worth considering for residents who prioritize safety.
What are the demographics of Bay Island?
Bay Island has a population of approximately 352. The median household income is $86,513. The median home value is $2,508,440. Research shows that economic factors can correlate with crime rates, though many other variables play a role in neighborhood safety.
How does Bay Island crime compare to the national average?
Bay Island's overall crime rate is 15% below the national average (index 85 vs 100). For the most accurate picture, review the per-crime-type breakdown above, as some categories may differ significantly from the overall trend.
Crime data sourced from FBI UCR reports and local law enforcement agencies. Crime indices use 100 as the national average. Updated April 2026.