Crime Safety Grade

A-

Middle Island, NY Crime Rate

Higher crime than 74% of U.S. cities

Based on FBI UCR & local law enforcement data · Updated March 2026

View Crime Map Registered Offenders

Is Middle Island Safe?

With an overall crime index of 131, Middle Island has a 31% higher crime rate than the national average. Your chance of becoming a victim of violent crime is 1 in 221. However, safety varies dramatically by neighborhood, with areas like Middle Island earning an A grade while Gordon Heights rates B.

Crime Index Comparison

Middle Island
131
New York Avg
101
National Avg
100

100 = national average. Higher values indicate more crime.

Crime Index
131
31% above average
Violent Crime
113
13% above average
Property Crime
117
17% above average
Safe Areas
100%
Neighborhoods rated A or B

Your chance of violent crime in Middle Island

1 in 221

Property crime: 1 in 214

Where Is It Safe in Middle Island?

Explore the Interactive Crime Map
See neighborhood-level heatmap
Check Registered Offenders
Search offenders near any address

Middle Island Crime Breakdown

Highest Risk
Murder · 45% above avg
Lowest Risk
Burglary · 13% below avg
Crime Type Index vs National
Murder Violent 145 ▲ 45%
Assault Violent 91 ▼ 9%
Robbery Violent 103 ▲ 3%
Burglary Property 87 ▼ 13%
Larceny / Theft Property 142 ▲ 42%
Vehicle Theft Property 121 ▲ 21%

Violent vs Property Crime

Neighborhood Safety Distribution

All Middle Island Neighborhoods

# Neighborhood Grade Crime Index
1 Middle Island A 116
2 Gordon Heights B 146

Middle Island Crime by Zip Code

11953
A- Index: 112

Middle Island Demographics & Cost of Living

Population
11,030
Median Income
$75,545
Home Value
$274,923
Median Rent
$1,718
Home Ownership
71%

Racial Demographics

White
70.7%
Black
16.2%
Hispanic
14.4%
Asian
4.9%

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the crime rate in Middle Island?
Middle Island has an overall crime index of 131, which is above the national average of 100. Approximately 100% of neighborhoods in Middle Island are rated A or B for safety.
Is Middle Island safe to live in?
Middle Island has a crime safety grade of A-. Very low crime. Safety varies significantly by neighborhood, so it is important to research specific areas before moving.
What are the safest neighborhoods in Middle Island?
The safest neighborhoods in Middle Island based on crime data include Middle Island, and Gordon Heights. These areas have the lowest crime indices in the city.
How does Middle Island crime compare to the national average?
Middle Island's overall crime index is 131 compared to the national average of 100, meaning crime is 31% higher than the typical US city.

Crime Statistics for Nearby Cities

Bridgeport, CT New Haven, CT Brookhaven, NY Islip, NY Oyster Bay, NY Babylon, NY Huntington, NY Smithtown, NY Norwalk, CT Brentwood, NY Fairfield, CT Southampton, NY West Haven, CT Milford city , CT Stratford, CT West Babylon, NY Shelton, CT Coram, NY Commack, NY Trumbull, CT Huntington Station, NY Central Islip, NY Riverhead, NY Bay Shore, NY

Crime Statistics by State

Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut Delaware Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming