St. Augustine, FL Crime Map

Explore crime rates, safest neighborhoods, and detailed crime statistics

St. Augustine Crime Rate Statistics

Overall Crime
8%
worse than
U.S. avg
Violent Crime
9%
worse than
U.S. avg
Property Crime
17%
worse than
U.S. avg
Safe Areas
100%
A/B rated
of neighborhoods

Based on 17 neighborhoods · Compared to U.S. average

Cost of living & quick facts
Optional details (kept collapsed to reduce clutter)
Show
Overall Cost
14%
14% more expensive
Housing Cost
12%
12% more expensive
Population
78,386
Median Income
$60,455
Home Value
$294,597
Median Rent
$1,118/mo

Cost index: 100 = U.S. national average.

Navigating the safety of any city is crucial for residents, visitors, and potential newcomers, and the St. Augustine crime map offers a detailed look into the safety landscape of this historic Florida gem. With an impressive average crime score of 0.056, St. Augustine earns a stellar overall crime grade of A, marking it as very safe compared to many other cities. Notably, an astounding 93.3% of the 15 analyzed neighborhoods in St. Augustine receive an A grade for safety, showcasing the city's strong commitment to security across most areas. Whether you're exploring the cobblestone streets of the historic district or considering a move to this charming coastal city with a population of 78,386, understanding the St. Augustine crime rate and neighborhood safety profiles can help you make informed decisions. This guide dives deep into the safest areas, local crime trends, and essential safety insights to ensure you can explore St. Augustine with confidence.

Understanding St. Augustine's Safety Landscape

St. Augustine, located in St. Johns County, Florida, is renowned for its rich history, stunning architecture, and vibrant community. With a population density of 610 people per square mile, the city strikes a balance between a small-town feel and the amenities of a larger urban area. The St. Augustine crime map reveals a city that prioritizes safety, as evidenced by its exceptional crime grade distribution. A remarkable 100% of neighborhoods fall into the A or B safety categories, with 14 out of 15 neighborhoods earning an A grade. This data highlights why St. Augustine safety is often a key draw for families, retirees, and tourists alike.

The city's demographics also paint a picture of a diverse and educated population, with a median age of 48 years and 38% of residents holding a college degree. However, challenges such as an 8.5% unemployment rate and a 17% poverty rate can influence local crime trends. Despite these factors, the overall St. Augustine crime rate remains low, reflecting effective community policing and resident engagement. For broader context on national crime statistics, you can refer to resources provided by the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, which offers valuable insights into crime patterns across the United States.

Safest Neighborhoods in St. Augustine

For those seeking the most secure areas to live or visit, the safe neighborhoods in St. Augustine stand out as exceptional choices. Based on the latest data from the St. Augustine crime map, the top five safest neighborhoods are shining examples of community safety and quality of life. These areas not only boast A+ crime grades but also offer higher median incomes and desirable living conditions.

  • The King & The Bear: With a population of 5,373 and a median income of $107,776, this neighborhood earns an A+ crime grade, making it one of the safest in the city. Its spacious layout and affluent community contribute to its secure environment.
  • Palencia: Home to 1,402 residents with a median income of $104,743, Palencia also secures an A+ grade for safety. Its well-maintained surroundings and active community watch programs enhance its appeal.
  • South Hampton Golf Club: This smaller enclave of 749 residents enjoys an A+ crime grade and a median income of $123,430, reflecting a tight-knit, secure community often centered around family-friendly amenities.
  • St. Johns Golf and Country Club: With just 649 residents and a median income of $123,393, this neighborhood's A+ safety rating is supported by private security measures and a low population density.
  • The Slammer & The Squire: Housing 1,238 people with a median income of $118,368, this area rounds out the top five with an A+ crime grade, offering peace of mind alongside upscale living.

These neighborhoods exemplify why St. Augustine safety is a hallmark of the city, providing ideal locations for families and individuals prioritizing security. Whether you're drawn to the golf-centric communities or the serene residential vibes, these areas consistently rank high on the St. Augustine crime map.

Areas Requiring Greater Awareness

While the majority of St. Augustine boasts impressive safety records, a few neighborhoods show slightly higher crime in St. Augustine and may require additional caution. It's important to approach these areas with an informed perspective rather than undue concern, as even the lowest-graded areas remain relatively safe compared to national averages. Neighborhoods such as Lincolnville, with a B- crime grade, and Royal St. Augustine, graded A-, are still considered secure but may experience occasional incidents that warrant awareness, especially for visitors unfamiliar with the area.

Other areas like Flagler's Model Land and Marsh Creek Country Club, both with A grades, and North Davis Shores, with an A+ grade, are notably safe but included here as they fall slightly below the top-tier neighborhoods in certain metrics. Residents and visitors can still feel confident in these communities by staying informed and practicing general safety precautions. The St. Augustine crime map provides a useful tool for identifying specific trends in these areas, ensuring you can navigate the city with a clear understanding of local dynamics.

Crime Trends and Local Factors

Understanding the broader context of crime in St. Augustine involves looking at both statistical trends and socioeconomic factors. The city's low average crime score of 0.056 reflects a community where violent and property crimes are significantly below national averages. This can be attributed to proactive law enforcement, community engagement programs, and the city's relatively affluent demographic profile, with a median home value of $294,597. However, challenges such as a 17% poverty rate and an 8.5% unemployment rate can contribute to isolated incidents, particularly in areas with lower median incomes like Lincolnville.

Seasonal tourism also plays a role in shaping the St. Augustine crime rate. As a historic destination, the city sees a surge in visitors, especially during peak seasons, which can lead to minor upticks in petty crimes such as theft in busier districts. Local authorities have responded with increased patrols and public safety initiatives to maintain St. Augustine safety. For more detailed crime data and trends, the Bureau of Justice Statistics provides comprehensive reports that can offer additional context on regional safety patterns.

Another factor to consider is the city's layout and infrastructure. With a population density of 610 per square mile, St. Augustine avoids the overcrowding issues seen in larger urban centers, which often correlate with higher crime rates. Neighborhoods with active homeowner associations and community watch programs, such as those in The King & The Bear and Palencia, further bolster local security. By staying aware of these trends and factors through tools like the St. Augustine crime map, residents and visitors can better understand the dynamics of safety in this historic city.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is St. Augustine safe?

Yes, St. Augustine is considered very safe, with an overall crime grade of A and an average crime score of 0.056. The majority of its neighborhoods—93.3%—earn an A grade for safety, and 100% fall into the A or B categories. This makes St. Augustine safety a standout feature, whether you're a resident or just visiting. While minor incidents can occur, particularly in busier tourist areas, the city's low St. Augustine crime rate and proactive policing ensure a secure environment for most.

What is the crime rate in St. Augustine?

The St. Augustine crime rate is notably low, reflected in the city's exceptional crime grade distribution. Of the 15 neighborhoods analyzed on the St. Augustine crime map, 14 (93.3%) receive an A grade, while the remaining 1 (6.7%) earns a B grade. This means 100% of neighborhoods are classified as safe, positioning St. Augustine as a secure place to live and visit compared to national averages.

What are the safest neighborhoods in St. Augustine?

The safe neighborhoods in St. Augustine include several standout communities with A+ crime grades. The top five are The King & The Bear, Palencia, South Hampton Golf Club, St. Johns Golf and Country Club, and The Slammer & The Squire. These areas, detailed on the St. Augustine crime map, offer exceptional safety, higher median incomes, and family-friendly environments, making them ideal for residents seeking peace of mind.

Is St. Augustine a good place to live?

St. Augustine is widely regarded as a great place to live, thanks to its high St. Augustine safety ratings, historic charm, and coastal beauty. With a median household income of $60,455 and a strong community focus, it appeals to families, retirees, and professionals alike. However, potential challenges like an 8.5% unemployment rate and a 17% poverty rate should be considered. Overall, the low St. Augustine crime rate and abundance of safe neighborhoods make it a desirable location for many.

Exploring St. Augustine with Confidence

Armed with insights from the St. Augustine crime map, you can explore this historic city with confidence, whether you're strolling through the safest neighborhoods like The King & The Bear or visiting iconic landmarks in the heart of town. St. Augustine's commitment to safety, reflected in its impressive A crime grade and low St. Augustine crime rate, ensures a welcoming environment for all. By staying informed about local trends and prioritizing St. Augustine safety, you can fully enjoy everything this charming Florida destination has to offer, from its rich history to its vibrant community spirit.

All 17 Neighborhoods in St. Augustine

Ranked by safety (safest first)
Rank Neighborhood Score Safety Median Income
#1 The King & The Bear A+ Exceptionally safe $107,776
#2 Palencia A+ Exceptionally safe $104,743
#3 South Hampton Golf Club A+ Exceptionally safe $123,430
#4 St. Johns Golf and Country Club A+ Exceptionally safe $123,393
#5 The Slammer & The Squire A+ Exceptionally safe $118,368
#6 South Davis Shores A+ Exceptionally safe $113,561
#7 Spanish Quarter A+ Exceptionally safe $68,655
#8 North Davis Shores A+ Exceptionally safe $68,310
#9 Lighthouse Park A+ Exceptionally safe $68,338
#10 Marsh Creek Country Club A Very safe $82,463
#11 Old City A Very safe $79,849
#12 Bannon Lakes A Very safe $60,100
#13 Sebastian Cove A Very safe $60,100
#14 Flagler's Model Land A Very safe $48,729
#15 Uptown A Very safe $68,426
#16 Royal St. Augustine A- Very safe $49,623
#17 Lincolnville B- Safe area $34,202

All 17 Neighborhoods by Crime Level

Ranked by crime (highest first)
Rank Neighborhood Score Safety Level Median Income
#1 Lincolnville B- Safe area $34,202
#2 Royal St. Augustine A- Very safe $49,623
#3 Uptown A Very safe $68,426
#4 Flagler's Model Land A Very safe $48,729
#5 Sebastian Cove A Very safe $60,100
#6 Bannon Lakes A Very safe $60,100
#7 Old City A Very safe $79,849
#8 Marsh Creek Country Club A Very safe $82,463
#9 Lighthouse Park A+ Exceptionally safe $68,338
#10 North Davis Shores A+ Exceptionally safe $68,310
#11 Spanish Quarter A+ Exceptionally safe $68,655
#12 South Davis Shores A+ Exceptionally safe $113,561
#13 The Slammer & The Squire A+ Exceptionally safe $118,368
#14 St. Johns Golf and Country Club A+ Exceptionally safe $123,393
#15 South Hampton Golf Club A+ Exceptionally safe $123,430
#16 Palencia A+ Exceptionally safe $104,743
#17 The King & The Bear A+ Exceptionally safe $107,776

St. Augustine Demographics Overview

14,906
Total Population
$81,180
Average Household Income
17
Neighborhoods Analyzed