Penfield, NY Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Penfield, NY

What is Penfield's overall crime grade and how does it compare to other cities?

Penfield earns an overall crime grade of A for 2026, placing it among the safest communities in New York State and well above the national average for suburban towns. This grade reflects consistently low incident rates across both violent and property crime categories. To put that in perspective, the town's poverty rate sits at just 4.4% and unemployment at 3.2% — both significantly below state and national benchmarks — which research consistently links to lower crime prevalence. Residents here are far less likely to encounter criminal activity than people living in comparably sized towns across the country.

What is the crime rate in Penfield, and which types of incidents occur most often?

Penfield's crime rate is exceptionally low for a community of 37,275 residents spread across a population density of just 386 people per square mile. When incidents do occur, property-related offenses — such as vehicle break-ins, minor theft, and occasional vandalism — represent the most common categories. Violent crime is rare. The town's strong economic foundation, with a median household income of $93,696, correlates directly with fewer economically motivated offenses. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office data consistently shows that the vast majority of reported incidents in Penfield are non-violent and isolated rather than part of recurring patterns.

Is Penfield safe to live in?

Yes — by nearly every measurable standard, Penfield is a very safe place to live. The town holds an A crime grade for 2026, and its socioeconomic indicators reinforce that picture: a poverty rate of only 4.4%, an unemployment rate of 3.2%, and a median household income approaching $94,000 all contribute to community stability. With a median home value of $215,833 and a median rent of $1,057, the housing market reflects a settled, invested residential base — factors that research ties to stronger neighborhood cohesion and lower crime. Families, retirees, and working professionals consistently rank Penfield among the most desirable and secure suburbs in the greater Rochester area.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Penfield?

Penfield's A-grade safety profile extends broadly across the town, but areas near Penfield Village and the corridors surrounding the Penfield Community Center are frequently cited by residents as particularly quiet and well-maintained. Neighborhoods adjacent to the Penfield Central School District campuses also benefit from high foot traffic, active neighborhood associations, and strong community visibility — all factors that deter opportunistic crime. The low overall population density of 386 residents per square mile means that even busier commercial pockets along Five Mile Line Road transition quickly into low-density residential zones with minimal incident history. Using the interactive crime map on this page, you can filter by incident type and date range to compare specific corridors in real time.

How does Penfield's income level affect its crime rate?

Economic stability is one of the strongest predictors of community safety, and Penfield's numbers tell a compelling story. With a median household income of $93,696 — roughly 40% above the U.S. median — and a poverty rate of just 4.4%, the town has a financial foundation that significantly reduces the conditions under which property and violent crime tend to rise. The unemployment rate of 3.2% is well below the national average, meaning fewer residents face the economic pressures that can drive opportunistic offenses. Combined with a stable housing market anchored by a median home value of $215,833, these indicators help explain why Penfield consistently earns top-tier crime grades year after year.

Is Penfield a good place to buy a home from a safety perspective?

From a safety standpoint, Penfield is an excellent choice for homebuyers. The town's A overall crime grade in 2026 signals that risk to property and personal safety is low relative to comparable markets. The median home value of $215,833 reflects strong demand without the pricing volatility seen in higher-crime markets, and the median rent of $1,057 suggests a healthy, stable rental segment as well. Low crime correlates with stronger long-term property value retention — homeowners in A-grade communities historically see less depreciation risk tied to neighborhood deterioration. Coupled with Penfield's 4.4% poverty rate and robust school district reputation, the town checks nearly every box for buyers prioritizing both safety and investment security.