Maitland, FL Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Maitland, FL

What is Maitland's overall crime grade?

Maitland, FL earns an overall crime grade of C+ for 2026. That places it in a moderate range — not among Florida's most dangerous cities, but not among the safest either. For context, Maitland's population of approximately 17,749 and a median household income of $79,821 contribute to a relatively stable community profile. A C+ grade means residents should stay informed and take reasonable precautions, particularly around property crime, which tends to drive crime grades in suburban cities like Maitland.

Is Maitland safe to live in?

With a C+ overall crime grade, Maitland is a moderately safe city by Florida standards. The city's socioeconomic indicators offer some reassurance: a median home value of $396,828, a median household income of $79,821, and an unemployment rate of just 4.4% all correlate with lower crime risk. The poverty rate of 10.1% is close to the national average, suggesting the community is largely stable. Most residents report feeling secure in day-to-day life, particularly in established residential areas near Lake Maitland and the Lake Sybelia corridor. That said, a C+ grade signals that property crime incidents do occur with enough frequency to warrant awareness.

What types of crime are most common in Maitland?

Like most suburban Florida cities, Maitland sees property crime as its dominant crime category — this includes incidents such as theft, vehicle break-ins, and residential burglary. Violent crime exists but is considerably less prevalent, keeping Maitland's overall grade from falling below a C+. Drug-related offenses occasionally surface as well, though they represent a smaller share of total incidents. The city's population density of 1,277 people per square mile is relatively low, which generally limits the concentration of crime hotspots compared to denser urban environments like downtown Orlando.

Which Maitland neighborhoods have lower crime rates?

Neighborhoods surrounding Lake Maitland and Lake Sybelia are consistently cited by residents as among the quieter, lower-incident areas in the city. The Maitland Oaks community and areas adjacent to Maitland City Hall also tend to benefit from active neighborhood associations and higher owner-occupancy rates, both of which are associated with reduced property crime. Conversely, areas closer to high-traffic commercial corridors — particularly near U.S. 17-92 — can see higher rates of opportunistic theft and vehicle-related incidents. Using the interactive crime map to filter by incident type and time period gives the most granular neighborhood-level picture.

How does Maitland's crime rate compare to the rest of Florida?

A C+ crime grade puts Maitland in the middle tier of Florida municipalities. Florida as a whole has historically had above-average property crime rates nationally, so a C+ in this state is neither exceptional nor alarming. Maitland's relatively high median household income of $79,821 and low unemployment rate of 4.4% help offset some of the risk factors that push other Orange County communities to lower grades. Compared to neighboring cities in the greater Orlando metro, Maitland generally performs better than higher-density urban cores but is broadly comparable to other mid-size suburban communities in the region.

What do Maitland's housing statistics tell us about safety?

Maitland's median home value of $396,828 and median rent of $1,461 indicate a housing market that skews toward stability and owner investment — factors that research consistently links to lower crime rates. Higher home values tend to correlate with residents who have a stronger financial stake in maintaining neighborhood quality. The city's 10.1% poverty rate, while not negligible, is moderate and does not suggest the concentrated economic distress that typically drives violent crime spikes. Taken together, these figures are consistent with Maitland's C+ crime grade: a city that is largely safe but not immune to the property crime pressures common across suburban Florida.

Is Maitland safe for families and retirees?

Yes — Maitland's C+ crime grade, combined with its strong income profile ($79,821 median household income), low population density (1,277 per sq mi), and access to quality parks and cultural amenities, makes it a reasonable choice for families and retirees. Violent crime rates remain low relative to larger metro areas, and the city's community policing initiatives contribute to a neighborhood-watch culture in areas like Lake Maitland Shores and Maitland Oaks. As with any city, reviewing the current crime map before choosing a specific street or subdivision is always a smart step, particularly to assess proximity to commercial zones where property crime tends to concentrate.