Circleville, OH Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Crime in Circleville, OH

Is Circleville, OH safe?

By the numbers, Circleville earns an overall crime grade of A — a strong indicator that the city performs significantly better than most comparably sized American towns. With a population of roughly 13,986 spread across a density of 751 residents per square mile, the city is compact enough for law enforcement to maintain meaningful coverage. Property crimes such as theft and vandalism account for the majority of reported incidents, while violent crime rates remain low relative to national benchmarks. That said, Circleville's poverty rate of 25.3% and unemployment rate of 8.6% are worth noting, as economic stress can correlate with opportunistic property crime in any community. Overall, the data supports Circleville as a genuinely safe place to live and visit.

What is the crime rate in Circleville, OH?

Circleville's crime profile earns an A grade overall, placing it among the safer small cities in Ohio. The city's median household income of $44,092 and median home value of $125,633 reflect a working-class community where property crime — particularly theft and burglary — tends to be the most common concern rather than violent offenses. The 25.3% poverty rate is notably higher than the national average of roughly 12–13%, which can elevate property crime risk in concentrated pockets of the city. However, the overall crime grade of A demonstrates that community policing efforts and neighborhood engagement have kept those risks well-managed. Residents should consult the interactive crime map on this page to track incident frequency by type and time period.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Circleville?

While Circleville's A overall crime grade reflects well on the city as a whole, safety does vary by area. Neighborhoods on the outskirts of the city, particularly those farther from commercial corridors and higher-density rental areas, tend to report fewer incidents. Areas near Pickaway County's rural edges benefit from lower population density and less foot traffic, which typically correlates with reduced opportunistic crime. Neighborhoods closer to downtown and high-traffic retail zones show a higher share of property crime incidents — consistent with national patterns where theft concentrates near commercial activity. With a median rent of $805, many of Circleville's rental-heavy blocks can see higher turnover and, in some cases, slightly elevated disturbance reports. Reviewing the crime map filters by neighborhood and incident type will give you the most current, block-level picture.

Is Circleville a good place to live in 2026?

For families and individuals prioritizing safety and affordability, Circleville presents a compelling case. The city's A crime grade is its strongest asset from a safety standpoint, and a median home value of just $125,633 makes homeownership far more accessible than in Ohio's larger metros. The median household income of $44,092 does reflect economic constraints, and the 8.6% unemployment rate — above the national average — signals that job market challenges persist. The poverty rate of 25.3% is the most significant socioeconomic risk factor for long-term crime trends, and prospective residents should monitor whether local economic development initiatives reduce that figure over time. On balance, Circleville's low crime profile, affordable housing, and tight-knit community culture — anchored by traditions like the annual Pumpkin Show — make it a reasonable choice for those who prioritize safety and cost of living over urban amenities.

How does Circleville's crime compare to other Ohio cities?

Circleville's overall A crime grade puts it ahead of many Ohio cities of similar and larger size. Cities with comparable populations but higher poverty and unemployment rates frequently score in the C or D range. Circleville's 25.3% poverty rate is notably high, yet the A grade suggests that local law enforcement, community programs, and neighborhood cohesion are effectively offsetting that socioeconomic pressure. In contrast, Ohio cities with poverty rates in a similar range but weaker community infrastructure often see B or C crime grades at best. For a city of under 14,000 residents with a population density of 751 people per square mile, maintaining an A-level safety profile is a meaningful achievement and a key quality-of-life differentiator for Pickaway County.