Bainbridge Island, WA Crime Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions: Bainbridge Island Crime & Safety

Is Bainbridge Island safe?

Bainbridge Island earns an overall crime grade of A — the highest possible rating — placing it among the safest communities in Washington State. Every single one of the six neighborhoods analyzed for 2026 received an A or A+ grade, meaning 100% of neighborhoods fall into the "safe" tier. The island's low poverty rate of 3.7% and unemployment rate of just 3.2% support the kind of stable socioeconomic conditions that correlate strongly with lower crime. For context, the median household income of $125,861 is well above national averages, and communities like Rolling Bay City and Yeomalt Point report median incomes as high as $157,759. Whether you're a prospective resident, a visitor, or someone researching the Bainbridge Island crime map, the data consistently points to a very safe environment.

What is the crime rate in Bainbridge Island?

Bainbridge Island's crime rate is exceptionally low by any meaningful measure. All six neighborhoods studied in 2026 received a letter grade of A or A+ — that's 100% of analyzed neighborhoods in the top safety tier, with zero neighborhoods graded B, C, D, or F. To put that in perspective, many comparable Pacific Northwest communities have 20–40% of neighborhoods falling below a B grade. The island's population density of just 347 residents per square mile contributes to a community-oriented atmosphere where residents tend to know their neighbors — a well-documented factor in crime deterrence. Areas like Pleasant Beach (A+) and Agate Point (A+) exemplify the island-wide pattern of minimal criminal activity, reinforcing Bainbridge Island's standing as one of the region's safest places.

What are the safest neighborhoods in Bainbridge Island?

Based on 2026 crime data, every analyzed neighborhood on Bainbridge Island is graded A or better — an extraordinary result that speaks to the island's uniformly safe character. Here's a breakdown of the top neighborhoods by safety grade:

• Pleasant Beach — A+: The top-ranked neighborhood, with a median household income of $139,394 and a population of about 96 residents. Its small size and tight-knit character contribute to outstanding safety outcomes.
• Agate Point — A+: Also earning the top A+ grade, Agate Point has a median income of $114,103 and approximately 178 residents. It consistently ranks among the island's most secure areas.
• Madrono Park — A: With roughly 263 residents and a median income of $110,976, Madrono Park maintains a strong A grade and a welcoming, low-crime environment.
• Wing Point Golf & Country Club — A: Home to about 438 residents and a median income of $127,785, this neighborhood blends community amenities with top-tier safety.
• Rolling Bay City — A: One of the higher-income neighborhoods at $157,759 median household income, Rolling Bay City's 323 residents enjoy an A-grade safety profile.
• Yeomalt Point — A: Matching Rolling Bay City's $157,759 median income, Yeomalt Point's 252 residents benefit from the same A-grade safety standing.

The fact that all 6 neighborhoods — 100% — earned an A grade or higher is rare among communities of any size and underscores why Bainbridge Island consistently ranks as one of Washington's safest places to live.

Is Bainbridge Island a good place to live?

The data makes a compelling case. Bainbridge Island's key livability indicators for 2026 include:

• Overall Crime Grade: A — city-wide safety rating of "Very Safe"
• 100% of neighborhoods graded A — zero neighborhoods below a B
• Median Household Income: $125,861 — significantly above the U.S. median
• Poverty Rate: 3.7% — one of the lowest rates in the Pacific Northwest
• Unemployment Rate: 3.2% — reflecting a healthy, stable local economy
• Median Home Value: $776,952 — indicating strong real estate demand and investment confidence
• Population: ~24,859 at a density of 347 per sq mi — large enough for amenities, small enough for community

Beyond the numbers, neighborhoods like Wing Point Golf & Country Club and Madrono Park offer a blend of natural surroundings and community cohesion that's difficult to find elsewhere. Families, retirees, and remote workers consistently cite the combination of safety, income stability, and quality of life as the primary reasons for choosing Bainbridge Island. With a median rent of $1,612 and a housing market that reflects sustained demand, the island is both a desirable and financially sound place to put down roots.

How does Bainbridge Island's safety compare to other Washington cities?

Bainbridge Island's A overall crime grade and 100% A-tier neighborhood rate place it in a very small group of Washington communities that achieve uniform top-tier safety across all analyzed neighborhoods. Most cities of comparable or larger population see a distribution of grades — typically a mix of A, B, C, and sometimes D or F neighborhoods. Bainbridge Island's 0% of neighborhoods below an A grade is a statistically notable outcome. Contributing factors include the island's geographic separation from mainland urban centers, its low population density of 347 people per square mile, and socioeconomic stability reflected in a poverty rate of just 3.7%. For anyone comparing communities on the Bainbridge Island crime map versus broader Kitsap County or the greater Seattle metro area, the island's safety profile stands out as exceptional.